JSON in Bash

09 September 2018

JSON cli tools

Bash is good for processing text, but nowadays a lot of stuff is JSON: configs, APIs, etc. And bash is horrible with manipulating JSON. Here we have various tool for processing JSON, and I think your heard or used one of them — jq.

But when I want to do something more complex with it I always fail as it has unfamiliar syntax, and, in fact, it is completely independent language. I wanted more simple and more familiar tool for working with JSON.

What is the best language to work with JSON? I think the answer is contained in its name — JavaScript Object Notation. So I created new tool 😁

In fact, two tools – in JavaScript and in Go:

  • fx (JavaScript, Node.js)
  • xx (Go, Otto, a JavaScript interpreter in Go)

Main idea what you can pipe any JSON in it and pass anonymous function as argument. That’s it. Nothing to remember. 🤗

$ echo '{"foo": [{"bar": "value"}]}' | fx 'x => x.foo[0].bar'

fx has a lot of useful features. For example to simple get value from JSON start with . (dot), and you will get an unquoted, raw value:

$ echo '{"foo": "value"}' | fx .foo

You can refer to passed JSON object by this keyword. And it’s possible to pass any number of anonymous functions for reducing JSON:

$ echo '{"foo": [{"bar": "value"}]}' | fx '.foo' 'this[0]' 'x => x.bar'

One of nice features of fx is updating JSON using spread operator:

$ echo '{"count": 100}' | fx '{...this, count: ++this.count}'
  "count": 101

Also fx and xx have standalone binaries (see releases pages on GitHub).

Eat 🧀

Also I’ve created tool called eat, which can “eat” everything including json, yaml, toml, xml, ini and output JSON for next processing with fx:

$ cat response.xml | eat | fx .Document.Title


Let’s benchmark fx/xx with jq. For it we will be using awesome hyperfine. We take jq’s example from tutorial on crunching GitHub API commit response.

cat commits.json | jq "[.[] | {message: .commit.message, name: .commit.committer.name, parents: [.parents[].html_url]}]"
cat commits.json | fx "this.map(x => ({message: x.commit.message, name: x.commit.committer.name, parents: x.parents.map(p => p.html_url)}))"
cat commits.json | xx "this.map(function (x) { return {message: x.commit.message, name: x.commit.committer.name, parents: x.parents.map(function (p) { return p.html_url;}) };})"

Benchmark 1

Node.js version was significantly slower then jq or xx. But this is due to big startup time of any node application. 🤔 What if we benchmark on a really big file?

ll big.json
-rw-r--r--  1 anton  staff    36M 9 sep 00:07 big.json

Benchmark 2

fx performs twice faster than jq written in C, and more than 3 times faster xx. But how JavaScript version can be faster? It’s because v8 faster jq, and otto.


So should we abandon jq? No, of course not. But I hope that these new tools can be useful for somebody. And they will find their users 👐.

Hi, I’m Anton. If you liked the post share it
If you found a typo edit post on GitHub.